The Break Room

Strategy? Idea? You bring it. We break it.
Off chance it survives :)
Maybe we find a backer.

Do you -- with your AI -- think all the ways your strategy can go wrong? We don’t think so. Our breakers come at it from angles you never thought about. Test your strategy or idea against real expertise, for free. Anonymously, if you want.

What this is, and what it isn’t

There are plenty of people testing public strategies and replicating papers, and some do it very well. This is not that.

This is for your strategy, or your idea — the thing you built and believe in. We break it the way the market would: costs, fills, capacity, what happens when it meets production. Every break has to be shown — a rerun, a chart, a number — not an opinion.

You can’t prove alpha. You can only try hard to disprove it, and see what’s left standing.

What to bring

It could be simply just an idea, or a track record (instrument, holding period, cost and fill assumptions, in-sample/out-of-sample split, any live record, equity curve).

Strategy? Results, no secrets please!

How it works

  1. Send it to us privately, by Substack message or email at tibor@tradingreality.com. Not in the chat.

  2. We pick what goes under the hammer. Not everything gets picked.

  3. We break it, and bring the breaks back to you. You can answer, fix it, or walk away.

  4. The verdict goes public, only with your consent: what broke, what held, and who broke it.

Anonymous is an option. We strip anything that could identify you, and your name goes on the write-up only if you want it there.

The rules

Some of these will need to be figured out as we go. A few have to hold:

  1. Don’t share anything proprietary. If it belongs to your employer, a client or anyone else, it stays out.

  2. Your own idea or strategy. If not, just share the source, and we will decide whether it can be “broken.”

  3. AI can be used, but not generically. If your idea or steer is not in the AI breakdown, don’t use it. Use your own words.

  4. Every break is specific and shown. “It won’t work” is not a break.

  5. No selling: no signals, no links to paid groups or courses.

  6. Hard on the strategy, never on the person.

Not yet disproven

If it survives, it survived these tests, on this data, as of this date. That’s all. Not an endorsement, not a guarantee, not investment advice.

To join, subscribe to Trading Reality (free is enough) and open the chat. This is not a promo for TR, though. Once done, you are free to leave.

Want to break instead? Become a breaker →

We break it so the market doesn’t.