Thank you, Tibor, at India NSE equity and index derivatives operate as a pure electronic order-driven continuous auction (limit order book) without formal continuous quoting obligations by market makers. Being a Trader, my options algo checks stale quotes on stock options at market opening, it regularly finds PE/CE spreads blown >150%, sometimes no bid-ask quotes for first 90 seconds. The algo checks whether the book is tradable: quotes are fresh, bid-ask spread within limits defined, book depth is available else it dynamically hedges (if outside delta band) via futures till the spread, quotes and liquidity appears. My current operational monitoring is at 500 milli seconds.
Given your background as MM, any good whitepapers, pointers for me to make my execution even more robust. What else can be done for better operations? Your guidance and help is appreciated.
at the open i would price the options off the futures, not off their own book. since dec 2025 NSE has the pre-open auction 9:00-9:15 for current month stock and index futures, options are not in it. so futures have a real price while the option books are still empty. build your fair value from the futures + your vol surface from the liquid strikes and only trade when a quote is near that, not just when the spread looks ok. there is a nice paper by Muravyev and Pearson on this (RFS 2020, “options trading costs are lower than you think”) - traders who time against fair value pay way less than the quoted spread, under 40% of it.
your delta band shouldnt be fixed either. Whalley & Wilmott (1997) is the classic one on optimal hedging bands with transaction costs. at the open your futures cost is higher so the band should be wider and then tighten as the book fills in
for a fair price inside a wide or one sided book look at Stoikovs micro-price
on ops - instead of polling every 500ms i’d check staleness on every update, exchange timestamp vs your receive time, so you know when the feed itself is late not only the quote. and log what your opening fills look like 1 and 5 min later. that tells you if trading the first minutes actually pays or not :)
Some time ago, I conducted an analysis of futures and options using OCC data, specifically aiming to understand the distinct role of market makers for both financial instruments.
From your perspective, could you confirm my interpretation or not?
These participants are what are typically described as the “sell side” of the market. Though they may not predominately sell futures, they do design and sell various financial assets to clients. They tend to have matched books or offset their risk across markets and clients. Futures contracts are part of the pricing and balancing of risk associated with the products they sell and their activities. These include large banks (U.S. and non-U.S.) and dealers in securities, swaps and other derivatives."
In my interpretation, these are the participants who use S&P 500 futures (which is my benchmark market in this analysis) as a hedge for their regulated activities in the equity market, where they are legally designated. In this regard, I have noticed over time a negative correlation between the net positions of market makers and asset managers.
Retail traders (like me) come up with many ideas, sometimes original, other times repackaged as new but actually old. However, the disadvantage of retail traders (i.e., cost, infrastructure, and expertise) is overwhelming.
In my opinion, what is left for the retail trader is to honestly assess how to improve upon the benchmark's performance based on his own personal utility curve, while trying to minimize execution costs. To use a simple example: I can improve the drawdown, or I can turn a bearish period into one where I still achieve a positive return, but I will pay for it with lower returns during the years when everyone else, including the benchmark, outperforms me. But since I am not a fund manager, I won't get fired for this.
And what I have noticed is that, at the retail level, a simple strategy can often outperform a machine learning algorithm.
Thank you, Tibor, at India NSE equity and index derivatives operate as a pure electronic order-driven continuous auction (limit order book) without formal continuous quoting obligations by market makers. Being a Trader, my options algo checks stale quotes on stock options at market opening, it regularly finds PE/CE spreads blown >150%, sometimes no bid-ask quotes for first 90 seconds. The algo checks whether the book is tradable: quotes are fresh, bid-ask spread within limits defined, book depth is available else it dynamically hedges (if outside delta band) via futures till the spread, quotes and liquidity appears. My current operational monitoring is at 500 milli seconds.
Given your background as MM, any good whitepapers, pointers for me to make my execution even more robust. What else can be done for better operations? Your guidance and help is appreciated.
good setup already. few things i’d look at
at the open i would price the options off the futures, not off their own book. since dec 2025 NSE has the pre-open auction 9:00-9:15 for current month stock and index futures, options are not in it. so futures have a real price while the option books are still empty. build your fair value from the futures + your vol surface from the liquid strikes and only trade when a quote is near that, not just when the spread looks ok. there is a nice paper by Muravyev and Pearson on this (RFS 2020, “options trading costs are lower than you think”) - traders who time against fair value pay way less than the quoted spread, under 40% of it.
your delta band shouldnt be fixed either. Whalley & Wilmott (1997) is the classic one on optimal hedging bands with transaction costs. at the open your futures cost is higher so the band should be wider and then tighten as the book fills in
for a fair price inside a wide or one sided book look at Stoikovs micro-price
on ops - instead of polling every 500ms i’d check staleness on every update, exchange timestamp vs your receive time, so you know when the feed itself is late not only the quote. and log what your opening fills look like 1 and 5 min later. that tells you if trading the first minutes actually pays or not :)
https://themarketjourney.substack.com/p/market-makers-in-options-and-futures
Some time ago, I conducted an analysis of futures and options using OCC data, specifically aiming to understand the distinct role of market makers for both financial instruments.
From your perspective, could you confirm my interpretation or not?
Thank you very much.
Thanks for reading this and engaging with it. I have dropped my thoughts into your comments.
Thank you very much for your time. Your comment on my article was highly valuable, and I consider it a very fair clarification regarding what I wrote.
Regarding the COT, the TFF's definition of a Market Maker is as follows:
https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/idc/groups/public/@commitmentsoftraders/documents/file/tfmexplanatorynotes.pdf
"Dealer/Intermediary
These participants are what are typically described as the “sell side” of the market. Though they may not predominately sell futures, they do design and sell various financial assets to clients. They tend to have matched books or offset their risk across markets and clients. Futures contracts are part of the pricing and balancing of risk associated with the products they sell and their activities. These include large banks (U.S. and non-U.S.) and dealers in securities, swaps and other derivatives."
In my interpretation, these are the participants who use S&P 500 futures (which is my benchmark market in this analysis) as a hedge for their regulated activities in the equity market, where they are legally designated. In this regard, I have noticed over time a negative correlation between the net positions of market makers and asset managers.
Retail traders (like me) come up with many ideas, sometimes original, other times repackaged as new but actually old. However, the disadvantage of retail traders (i.e., cost, infrastructure, and expertise) is overwhelming.
In my opinion, what is left for the retail trader is to honestly assess how to improve upon the benchmark's performance based on his own personal utility curve, while trying to minimize execution costs. To use a simple example: I can improve the drawdown, or I can turn a bearish period into one where I still achieve a positive return, but I will pay for it with lower returns during the years when everyone else, including the benchmark, outperforms me. But since I am not a fund manager, I won't get fired for this.
And what I have noticed is that, at the retail level, a simple strategy can often outperform a machine learning algorithm.